Games with best stories!

Best stories? Hmm, ok, off the top of my head:
To The Moon
Spec Ops: The Line
Amnesia: The Dark Descent
Bioshock
Alan Wake

HOME!

Planescape: Torment, Half-Life, Bloodlines, Fallout 1, Spec Ops: The Line, Thief 1&2, NWN Mask of the Betrayer, Grim Fandango, System Shock 2, Silent Hill 2.

Grandia -- A tale of kid, who wants nothing more to be an adventurer and fight epic battles. Then goes on his adventure and grows up. Love, loss, wonder, duty and self sacrifice. Gets me every time.

Lunar 2 Eternal Blue -- A love story, with excellent characters each with their own backstory. Characters change over time. Still to date, my favorite game of all time. Also, the first game I ever played with an Epilogue that gave a second equally awesome and satisfying ending.

Both are old school JRPGs. Complete with beautiful music, cinematic, and voice acting.

witcher, alice madness returns (the story itself turned quite unexpected for me and i was pleased with that), i like bioschock too and vampire th masquerade

For me, the first game that touched myself emotionally was Knights of the Old Republic by far (The first one, the second didn't touched me at all), never found a game that gave me the satisfaction and the emotions that KotOR gave to me.

Hopefully This will help you, see you soon ^^

Haven't finished it yet, but Spec Ops: The Line has one of the best stories around. Not too complicated plot, but the game actually shows how gruesome war can be.

Spec Ops The Line
The Gameplay is Linear AS HELL
But the story makes up for it.

Ohhh although it's a common kind of story, I liked how the story was made in the Age of Mithology, when I was young, the story really catch me and made me feel like I was in the game.
one that I hate and love so much is Dead Island, the story of the game is so catchy, but it's not well connected with the gameplay and ends like a pile of bullshit, I must admit that I thought a lot about the story of the game while I was playing, although it's just borderlands in a zombie apocalypse

Red Dead Redemption, Kingdom Hearts, Final Fantasy VII,Ico, Shadow of the Colossus and Uncharted 2.

Final Fantasy VIII or IX or VII for that matter.. X as well.. :D All FF games basically.

Silent Hill 2, Planescape Torment, Bastion.

Thomas Was Alone

fallout 3

Shenmue

Mass Effect

Spec Ops The Line
Mass Effect Trilogy
Dragon Age Origins
Half Life
Walking Dead as well :D

Maybe Sleeping Dogs

These games really made me emotional:

• The Walking Dead (so many surprises with characters I actually cared for)
• Spec Ops: The Line (I questioned everything I did)
• Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 (Shooting dozens of civilians in an airport was hard)

Kingdom Hearts

Mass Effect was good. But I think the one (and possibly only) game that REALLY made me go "wait, what?!" is Dragon Age: Origins. When faced with a very... let's call it awkward... choice with a female character towards the end I actually had to stop to think for a second. Then the video game part of my mind kicked in and said "I totally want to see where this goes with the ridiculous option!"

And though it is a moot point now (the servers closed in November,) City of Heroes had some very solid storylines too. Rest in peace Lorne Lightningclaw.

Edit: Half-Life 2 and its episodes have great narrative too. As does Portal 1+2 to an extent - valve games definitely play the silent protagonist. But they are well worth the playthrough to anybody who hasn't done so yet

Time Fcuk

You already mentioned The Walking Dead, so I guess you're not too squeamish. I'd recommend Silent Hill 2, exactly the second one — it was and still pretty much is the Shakespeare of gaming, though you'd have to endure the voice acting which is just atrocious. Then the recent Thirty Flights of Loving is very lovingly crafted, if you like having a few sleepless nights thinking "what the hell happened". Then there is Portal, but I'm pretty sure you already played it (if not — DO IT!). Psychonauts were quite good at the time, if you're a fan of light stuff that doesn't clog up your thinking pipes. If you're more into epic world-building, then pick whichever Bioware title tickles your fancy.

Mass Effect, everything is good except the ending IMO

mass effect series